Unit 4 critical assessment mba615



Initial Critical Assessment

Respond to the following topic to present to your peers in a professional analysis using a minimum of 350 words.


The easiest way to forecasting earnings is linear extrapolation: gathering the historic financial data and deriving a growth rate (CAGR) for any line on the income statement (sales, gross profit, operating profit, net income etc). If historically profit ratios have been constant you can just forecast sales and derive the rest as a percentage of sales. Companies could then monitor competitors to confirm profit margins are close to industrial average.

A more comprehensive way is understanding the product, assess the macro environment (GDP growth) and the prospects of that market. Can the company increase market share? Do a Porter analysis.

Break down the income and expense components of the earnings and see how each item can change in the future (e.g. a cheese factory needs to buy and store milk, what volumes can it support using existing assets?). Management must create a model for what drives the company.

Forecasting each “moving part” of the company with forward looking quantitative and qualitative justifications is more reliable than just applying a flat rate based on historic performance.

In summary company valuation should include meeting with management and visiting the company unless everything is available and can be researched from your computer. 

What are your thoughts on this summary of forecasting earnings? Why would we want to forecast a company’s earnings?  How would managers and investors use this information? Which of these approaches do you agree with? Which ones do you think would be of little value and why?

Your critical response should have a minimum of two sources published in the last 12 months which should be used to support the content within the postings, proper in-text citations.  Your responses should be professionally written and correctly formatted references should be prepared consistent with the APA. The list of references should be physically positioned at the end of the postings.